Safe Safe Episode 18 looks at the difference between residential and commercial safes (aka high-security safes), focusing on value, security, and practicality. While residential safes emphasize appearance, high-security safe models prioritize maximum protection, making the best choice dependent on value and future needs.
Learn more about Vaultek in Episode 18.
ASK A QUESTION
Have a question about safes, vault doors, the state of the industry, or even our favorite local burger spot? Sign up for updates about the next Safe Space podcast and get an exclusive link to submit a question.
Episode 18 Discussion Questions
2:11: Why would a homeowner choose a commercial safe over a residential safe?
12:26: What is the most popular commercial safe business owners buy and why?
16:07: Are there any commercial gun sales?
25:50: What are the benefits of having a residential safe over a commercial safe?
Episode 18 Discussion Question Synopses
2:11: Why would a homeowner choose a commercial safe over a residential safe?
When determining the right safe, the most important factor is the value — both monetary and sentimental — of what it will protect. For customers with precious metals, jewelry, firearms, or heirlooms, a high-security safe (aka a commercial safe) is generally recommended once items exceed $75K in value, though sometimes less.
Beyond financial worth, personal meaning matters. One of the most remarkable things a customer needed to protect was a 500-year-old family Bible. The item was priceless to them, regardless of resale value.
Practical considerations also play a role, such as installation limits and future planning. Even if someone only has $20K worth to secure right now, they may accumulate far more over time, making a higher-rated safe the smarter investment.
In a world where ‘bigger is better,’ the MAX1014 proves that despite its small size, it offers big protection.
5:09: If a customer wanted the best of both worlds somewhere between a commercial safe and residential safe, what would you recommend and why?
When people talk about home safes, they usually mean something smaller than a full-size gun safe, often about 42 inches tall instead of five feet. One of the strongest choices in this size is the BF series from American Security (AMSEC).
Most home safes are made from thin metal and sheetrock, but the BF series is built differently. It has double walls, concrete filling, thick insulation, a solid steel door, and extra reinforcement. This makes it as strong as many commercial safes, while still easy to use in a house.
Many people use BF safes to protect valuables worth $75,000–$100,000, though they work well for smaller collections too. Another good option is a Fort Knox safe, which can be upgraded with stronger steel for more protection. Fort Knox safes may cost more, but they are customizable, stylish, and made in the USA. Both brands offer strong security, fire safety, and long-lasting reliability.
8:30 What steps would a customer have to go through to put a 2,000 pound safe in the ground floor of their home?
When it comes to placing heavy safes in a home, flooring strength is a common concern. In many cases, standard wood subfloors can handle far more weight than people expect. Contractors can add reinforcement with blocks and posts, but often it isn’t necessary. Safes weighing 1,600 to 2,000 pounds are regularly installed without issue, as the weight is spread out evenly across the base.
Even older homes have supported large safes without reinforcement, provided the path into the house is stable. In fact, most modern floors can hold up to 4,000 pounds in a 10-by-10 room.
The bigger challenge is often the delivery path — stairs, decks, or weak entry points — rather than the floor itself. Licensed contractors can provide peace of mind with quick inspections, but safe installation crews have decades of experience proving that heavy safes can be placed securely, even upstairs. The misconception that 1,000–3,000 pounds is “too heavy” simply isn’t true.
If you want the best, invest in ISM.
12:26: What is the most popular commercial safe business owners buy and why?
In the past few years, safe requirements have changed because of crime and insurance rules. After 2021, during COVID, there were many big break-ins since criminals had more time to work without being noticed. This caused insurance companies to ask for stronger safes, and many businesses moved from TL-30 safes to TL-30x6 models.
A TL-15 safe usually covers about $250,000 in insurance, a TL-30 covers about $750,000, and a TL-30x6 can cover up to $1 million. Some insurance companies now even require TRTL safes for businesses with a lot of inventory. For many people, it makes sense to buy a stronger safe early, so they are ready as their needs grow.
Today, both businesses and homeowners are choosing these high-security safes from trusted brands like American Security and ISM. They provide better protection for valuables and peace of mind for the future.
16:07: Are there any commercial gun sales?
American Security stands out as one of the only manufacturers offering a true out-of-the-box TL-30x6 safe. The AMSEC RF7036, AMSEC RF5828 TL30x6, and AMSEC RF6528, combine commercial-grade protection with gun safe interiors, making them ideal for garages, shops, or high-value collections.
These safes come equipped with features like interior lighting and door panels, while delivering the same level of protection demanded by businesses securing millions of dollars in assets. Browning also offers a TL-30, built by INKAS.
But American Security leads the industry in TL-rated gun safes available directly from the factory. Beyond these, ISM safes such as TRTL-30x6 and TRTL-60x6 can be customized with gun safe interiors for unmatched security. While few companies provide these solutions, American Security and ISM have resisted cutting corners and maintained top-tier quality. For individuals with assets worth hundreds of thousands, investing $20,000–$25,000 in this level of safe is a practical long-term decision.
19:04: What are the biggest security differences between a commercial and residential safe? Steel, concrete trading, etc.?
Most home gun safes are made from thin metal, usually 12- or 14-gauge steel, which is less than an inch thick. For fire protection, they often use layers of sheetrock, the same material found in house walls. When heated, sheetrock lets out moisture to help cool the safe, but the inside can still reach 220–350 degrees during a fire.
Commercial safes are much stronger. They have double walls filled with concrete, steel plates, ceramics, or even carbon to stop cutting tools and torches. American Security adds steel mesh and deflector plates to slow down break-ins.
ISM goes even further, using a special alloy mix with a hardened steel grid, called alchronite. This design spreads out heat and makes drilling very hard. Because of these materials, commercial safes are tougher, longer-lasting, and give much better fire protection than regular home safes.
23:08: At what dollar value of assets would you recommend a customer buy a commercial safe or a residential safe?
When deciding on a safe, both dollar value and personal meaning matter. Many experts suggest that once someone is protecting $75K–$100K in assets, a TL-rated safe becomes essential. However, even $30K in valuables may justify upgrading, since guns, jewelry, and heirlooms often can’t be easily replaced or fully insured.
Cash, in particular, has no insurance protection, making a stronger safe even more critical. Some recommend Fort Knox safes with AR500 steel for those seeking higher-end finishes and advanced resistance against tools and torches. Ultimately, the threshold depends on the individual, but $75K is widely seen as the standard benchmark.
25:50: What are the benefits of having a residential safe over a commercial safe?
Residential safes are often made to look nice, with shiny finishes and extra details that appeal to homeowners. Commercial safes, however, are built for strength and security, not style. Many of them weigh over 2,000 pounds and are designed to handle serious break-in attempts.
Most businesses care more about performance than looks, so commercial safes don’t usually have the polished appearance of high-end residential models.
American Security is one brand that offers both. Their BF series combines tough construction with a clean design, making it a favorite for homeowners who want strong protection without giving up style.