Safe deposit boxes have protected important documents, jewelry, precious metals, and family heirlooms for generations. But as more banks phase out this service, many customers are wondering what to do next. At NW Safe, we help customers understand their options and choose a safe that provides the right level of burglary and fire protection for the valuables they are bringing home.
ASK A QUESTION
Have a question about safes, vault doors, the state of the industry, or even our favorite local burger spot? Sign up for updates about the next Safe Space podcast and get an exclusive link to submit a question.
Episode 68 Topics
00:00 — Why Safe Deposit Boxes Are Disappearing
03:08 — Don't Replace Security With a Cheap Safe
04:56 — Consider Access and Where You Store Valuables
07:11 — Match the Safe to the Value
08:33 — Why We Often Recommend TL-15 or Better
11:21 — Understanding TL-15, TL-30 and Higher Security
13:36 — Balancing Security, Fire Protection and Price
Episode 68 Discussion Synopsis
00:00 — Why Safe Deposit Boxes Are Disappearing
For decades, safe deposit boxes were a common place to store important documents, jewelry, precious metals, cash, and family heirlooms. Today, that is changing. We are hearing from more customers whose banks are closing or eliminating safe deposit boxes.
There are several reasons. Younger customers often rely more on digital records and assets. Banks are also shrinking their physical locations and changing how branches are designed. Large vaults take up valuable space, while managing safe deposit boxes requires staff time and added security procedures. For many banks, they simply are not profitable enough to maintain.
03:08 — Don't Replace Security With a Cheap Safe
When customers lose access to a safe deposit box, one of the biggest mistakes we see is buying an inexpensive safe online or at a warehouse store.
The problem is simple: the level of protection may not match the value of what is being stored.
Many people have kept their most important possessions in safe deposit boxes for years. That can include wills, trusts, jewelry, precious metals, cash, and irreplaceable family items. Moving those valuables into a basic home safe can create a major security gap.
We recommend choosing a safe based on what you need to protect, not simply the purchase price.
Safety deposite box alternatives.
04:56 — Consider Access and Where You Store Valuables
Private vault companies can be another option, but they come with many of the same access concerns as bank safe deposit boxes. If the business is closed when you need something, you may have to wait.
Keeping valuables at home gives you more control over when you can access them. However, that does not mean everything needs to go into one safe.
For customers with significant valuables, we may recommend splitting assets between a high-security home safe and another secure location. This helps avoid putting everything in one place.
07:11 — Match the Safe to the Value
A $500 safe should not be expected to provide the same protection as a bank vault. This is especially important when storing heirloom jewelry, precious metals, important documents, or other items that cannot easily be replaced.
We generally encourage customers replacing a safe deposit box to consider a commercial-grade safe. Depending on the safe, placing it in a garage and properly bolting it down can provide strong security while also making a heavier safe easier to accommodate.
It is also smart to think about future storage needs. A slightly larger safe today can prevent the need to replace it later.
08:33 — Why We Often Recommend TL-15 or Better
For higher-value storage, we often start the conversation with a TL-15-rated safe or better.
The difference becomes clear when looking at construction. Many common safes use relatively thin steel. In our own testing discussed in the transcript, a 16-gauge safe body was cut open in about one minute and 20 seconds. A TL-15-rated safe required stronger tools and about 45 minutes under ideal testing conditions.
Compact TL-rated safes also have another advantage: weight. Even a relatively small model can weigh around 400 to 500 pounds. Their compact shape and low center of gravity can make them extremely difficult to move, especially when properly installed.
Quick Synopsis: Designed to resist sustained attacks from professional-grade tools, TL-30 safe safes offer significantly more security than traditional residential gun safes. Among the most respected options in this category is the ISM Bullion TL-30 Safe, a model built specifically for protecting gold, silver, jewelry, cash, and other high-value assets.
11:21 — Understanding TL-15, TL-30 and Higher Security
The right security rating depends on what you are protecting. For residential customers storing roughly $30,000 to $50,000 in valuables, we often see a TL-15 safe as a strong place to start.
As values climb into the hundreds of thousands of dollars, higher-rated options become worth considering. However, customers should understand the construction differences between ratings. Moving into safes with reinforced protection on all six sides can provide another major increase in security. For values reaching into the millions, even higher-rated commercial safes may be appropriate.
This is why we do not recommend choosing a safe based on price alone. The amount and type of valuables inside should help determine the appropriate level of protection.
13:36 — Balancing Security, Fire Protection and Price
Not everyone replacing a safe deposit box needs the highest-rated commercial safe available. For some customers, models such as the American Security BFS Series can provide a middle ground between inexpensive home safes and heavier TL-rated options.
The BFS Series uses steel construction with a concrete-based fire fill. Depending on the model, it also includes features such as solid steel plate doors and independently tested fire protection.
Fire ratings also deserve careful attention. Not every advertised fire rating is based on the same testing process, and some manufacturers test only one size within a larger product line. We encourage customers to look beyond the number of minutes printed on the label and understand how the safe was actually tested.
For customers facing the closure of a safe deposit box, the most important advice is simple: don't impulse buy. Start by looking at what you are storing, how much it is worth, the level of fire and burglary protection you need, and where the safe will be installed. From there, we can help match the safe to the value you actually need to protect.